Skip to content
Crap Movies Club, home

9 picks · a night at the video store

Bad Christmas movies and festive cult oddities

Festive cheer, with several serious complications.

Crap Movies Club editorial · Updated

Christmas gives a bad-movie night a shared visual language before the film starts: Santa, toys, snow and an expectation that everyone will behave a little better. These films find remarkably different ways to disrupt that expectation.

The shelf splits between strange holiday fantasies and adult horror. Keep those categories in mind when inviting people. A rubber snowman can still appear in a nasty slasher, while a cheap Martian set may belong to a much gentler children’s adventure.

Before you press play

For a curious mixed group, begin with the two older Santa fantasies. For an informed adult horror crowd, Santa’s Slay and The Toy Maker offer more immediate mayhem. Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny and Elves are slow curiosities to save for people who enjoy the waiting as well as the payoff.

Go straight to the double feature ↓
  1. 01 / 1964 · 81 min

    Santa Claus Conquers the Martians

    CrapScore 81 / 100 · How we score

    Kidnapping Santa becomes a parental solution to Martian childhood unhappiness. The earnest festive message and conspicuously modest space hardware make an approachable seasonal curiosity.

    For your group: A children's-film rhythm with awkward comedy and substantial setup.

  2. 02 / 1959 · 94 min

    Santa Claus

    CrapScore 82 / 100 · How we score

    The elaborate Santa headquarters and meddling devil offer a holiday universe unfamiliar to many viewers. Put it on for friends who enjoy discovering how differently a familiar figure can be imagined.

    For your group: Dreamlike and occasionally unsettling for children; it is the 1959 Mexican film.

  3. 03 / 2005 · 85 min

    Santa's Slay

    CrapScore 64 / 100 · How we score

    A wrestler's physical presence gives murderous Santa an immediately clear method. Its opening burst of chaos makes this an effective adult-horror alternative to a slow festive build-up.

    For your group: Bloody violence, crude jokes and a story that cannot maintain the opening's pace throughout.

  4. 04 / 1991 · 86 min

    Silent Night, Deadly Night 5: The Toy Maker

    CrapScore 64 / 100 · How we score

    A toy shop gives the Christmas setting a practical role in the menace. The increasingly odd family mystery makes it useful for viewers who want a story to unravel as well as dangerous presents.

    For your group: Disturbing family and sexual material accompanies the rubbery toy horror.

  5. 05 / 1987 · 88 min

    Silent Night, Deadly Night Part 2

    CrapScore 85 / 100 · How we score

    The opening recap makes the film an eccentric object before the central performance takes over. Choose it for a group interested in outrageous line delivery and unusually economical sequel construction.

    For your group: Extensive reused footage and slasher violence; patience is needed before its best-known moments.

  6. 06 / 1997 · 86 min

    Jack Frost

    CrapScore 78 / 100 · How we score

    The chemical transformation gives a familiar snowman a serial killer's priorities. It is an adult choice for viewers who enjoy deliberately terrible seasonal puns and visibly ridiculous monsters.

    For your group: Includes sexual assault and cruel comic violence. Check that the whole group is comfortable with that material.

  7. 07 / 1972 · 70 min

    Santa and the Ice Cream Bunny

    CrapScore 78 / 100 · How we score

    The Florida beach and very patient rescue attempt provide a strange alternative to snowy holiday imagery. The long fairy-tale detour is part of its identity, not an interruption a faster edition necessarily fixes.

    For your group: Extremely slow and available in differing versions. Best for a small, committed curiosity night.

  8. 08 / 1989 · 89 min

    Elves

    CrapScore 70 / 100 · How we score

    A department-store Christmas becomes tangled with a conspiracy far larger than the lone creature seems equipped to handle. The disproportion is its main conversational attraction.

    For your group: Nazi breeding themes, sexual threat and slow exposition make this a difficult fit for casual festive fun.

  9. 09 / 2018 · 97 min

    Anna and the Apocalypse

    CrapScore 62 / 100 · How we score

    The Christmas setting and school musical give the zombie outbreak a recognisable emotional world. It is a useful change from another Santa slasher when the group is happy for the action to stop for songs.

    For your group: Teen drama, bloody deaths and abrupt tonal shifts. The musical format is essential to the choice.

TWO TAPES, ONE EVENING

Our double feature

  1. Santa Claus Conquers the Martians · 81 min
  2. Santa Claus · 94 min

Santa Claus Conquers the Martians turns Christmas into an interplanetary rescue. Follow it with the 1959 Mexican Santa Claus, where gadgets and a devil create an entirely different holiday mythology. The contrast is stranger and gentler than pairing two slashers.

Research and further reading

Film details and posters come from TMDB. Explore the reviews below for more on these films.

Another kind of movie night

All movie-night guides →

TYPE A TITLE. TYPOS ARE FINE._